Right now, Brazil’s presidential election is the biggest fight to preserve Brazilian democracy.
This Sunday, the second round of Brazil’s presidential election takes place, in which Luis Inácio Lula da Silva, the country’s current center-left president, will face Flávio Bolsonaro, a Brazilian senator and the son of the country’s former president, Jair Bolsonaro.
To understand what is at stake, we have to understand how fragile Brazilian democracy has been over the past decade, and what made it so.
What is Beyond The Simple ‘Left vs Right’ Narrative
On the surface, it wouldn’t look much different from a presidential election in a deeply and nearly evenly divided country.
On one side, we have Lula: an unmatched political force in the country for over four decades. Coming from poverty himself, Lula lifted millions of Brazilians out of poverty in his first two terms (2003-2011) via social programmes, expanded access to education, increased the minimum wage, and other policies that benefited the working class. Lula left his second with approval ratings rarely seen in history: over 80 per cent. His third, current term has also seen strong economic growth, rising real incomes, and a reduction in food insecurity so significant that it allowed Brazil to be removed from the UN world hunger map again, after falling back into it during Jair Bolsonaro’s rule.
Lula is a skilled diplomat at home and a dedicated multilateralist, navigating Brazil’s relations with other Latin American states, BRICS countries, and even Donald Trump, who has tried to punish the Brazilian economy with high tariffs since 2025.
On the other side, we have Flávio Bolsonaro: a far-right Brazilian senator and the candidate supported by the Evangelical church, whose conservative political agenda rotates around traditional family, opposing LGBTQ+ rights, the teaching of gender studies, abortion (which is currently illegal in Brazil), and secularism itself. This comes with his hard-on-crime political agenda that some compare to Nayib Bukele’s, the Salvadoran president’s, approach to incarceration (e.g., mega prisons). Flávio has also made promises to bring Brazil closer to the U.S. by strengthening military cooperation and opening Brazil’s mineral markets to U.S. companies. Unsurprisingly, Flávio, unlike Lula, is a loud pro-Israel presidential candidate who has promised, following Colombia’s lead, to move the Brazilian embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem.
However, it is crucial to understand that what Flávio Bolsonaro represents is not a traditional political right (fiscal policy, size of government, etc.). Journalists and political analysts warn that this is an anti-system candidate who, if ascended to power, would try to dismantle democratic mechanisms by weakening the system of checks and balances in the country (the power of courts, the protections of freedom of speech, etc.). To understand what this fear is based on, we have to go back at least a decade.
Democracy Starts to Shake
I myself lived in Brazil between 2014 and 2017. I saw how the country fell for what can be called a parliamentary coup in 2016, when the then-president Dilma Rousseff was impeached by a highly corrupt Congress to advance a neoliberal agenda. It was the beginning of concerted efforts by the far-right to derail Brazilian democracy, which later resulted in an unlawful arrest of Lula himself, preventing him from running in 2018, and resulting in far-right Jair Bolsonaro winning the race.
Lula was then acquitted and returned to Brazilian politics by winning the 2022 presidential election. His government, and Brazilian democracy itself, survived Jair Bolsonaro’s coup attempt, which culminated in an insurrection on January 8, 2023, when Bolsonaro supporters attacked federal buildings in the capital, Brasília. For plotting the coup and other charges, Bolsonaro is currently serving a 27-year house arrest sentence.
Bolsonarismo, however, is very much alive. The antidemocratic far-right hasn’t gone anywhere while Lula was in power. So when Flávio claims that, once elected, he will change the constitution and “redemocratise the country“, we have to ask what it could actually mean. Especially while one of his election promises was granting amnesty to his father – someone who, once again, has not only praised the Brazilian military dictatorship that ruled the country for over two decades, but who was plotting to overturn its democratically elected government just three years ago.
How Much Is at Stake
It is impossible to overstate what is at stake here. These are the rights of Brazilian workers, its women, the socio-economic situation of its black population, and much more.
At stake is also the safety and well-being of its Indigenous Peoples. Loosening environmental regulations, another promise of Flávio, and opening Indigenous lands for agriculture could mean more deforestation in the Amazon, the critical forest that supports the health of our planet’s ecosystems. Local Communities and Indigenous People who live there already face violence from illegal loggers and miners, and have raised the alarm that Flávio’s presidency would put them into greater danger, and might also see the Ministry of Indigenous Peoples, created by Lula in 2023, abolished.
That is why we have been seeing massive marches across the country: they’re about more than Lula and his Workers’ Party. They are against the comeback of fascism to the highest post in the country.
In the end, they’re fighting for the survival of Brazilian democracy itself.
As always, stay strong, check on others, and keep your heart open.
❤️💔❤️
Justina
If you value this work, please consider supporting it.
The Exploding Head is a complete one-woman show: everything you see, hear, and read is produced solely by me. Your support lets me spend more time researching, writing, and creating — and helps keep this work accessible to everyone.
Stay Connected
Get new analysis directly in your inbox.