The Threat to The Israeli Democracy Is Real – But The Israeli Democracy Isn’t

Israeli protests in 2023

In democracies, when courts are losing their independence, it IS alarming.

And I would say, it IS alarming in Israel, too.

But what else is alarming? What is a must to talk about when we talk about the “threat to the Israeli democracy”?

Israelis have been protesting on the streets for months, for reasons that should be understood in any democracy: its far-right government has a plan to implement measures to limit the power of the country’s courts.

If it wasn’t happening in Israel, this is where the scandalousness (is that a word? Well, it would surely apply to situations like this) would end.

But precisely because it’s happening in Israel, there is so much to talk about.

In my episode, I present three points.

One, I talk about how democracy is (or isn’t) defined in political science.

In short, it’s not as straightforward as you think and I have a whole article on it here that I will shamelessly recommend. You can find more information on the example of Poland and its deteriorating judicial independence that I give in this part of my episode here.

Two, I ask if – no matter how simple the definition of democracy we chose to use is – we can actually call Israel a democracy.

“Democracy for some” – are we in on this concept?

When five million Palestinians living in its territory (the territories Israel illegally occupies and besieges) are neither citizens nor people with any kind of autonomy, do we say it doesn’t matter?

Three, I point to the violent response that protesters in Israel have seen from the Israeli forces.

I mention The Great March of Return in Gaza and the recent killing of a 15-year-old Palestinian girl, Jana Majdi Zakarneh, by an Israeli sniper.

It’s a dense episode. But that’s because there’s so much to talk about. Thank you in advance for listening to it and for sharing it with the broader community of people who care.

Justina


As promised, here’s an excellent video explaining Israel’s judicial reforms in greater detail:


PS. I’ve also filmed a quick video for you to share with the ones who might benefit from listening to my podcast:

Stay Connected

Get new analysis directly in your inbox.

Follow my work on social media:

Latest from the Blog

Autonomous Weapons Systems, AI and Warfare: A Conversation with Nicole van Rooijen

If you are concerned about the use of AI in warfare, you should be. Digital dehumanisation – people reduced to data points – is both very much real and, in some cases, lethal. Watch my conversation with Nicole van Rooijen, the Executive Director of Stop Killer Robots, and learn about what we can do collectively…

On Admiring Those Who Bomb Hospitals

Before 2023, it wasn’t controversial to think that bombing hospitals and mass murdering medics should receive widespread condemnation. Yet what Israel’s systematic destruction of Gaza’s healthcare system, including its hospitals, has shown, is that such actions might even give you credit to be seen as a leader in the field, as the example of my…

A Conversation with Author Benjamin Moser You Have to Watch

Watch an excellent conversation on Deep Dive Palestine with author Benjamin Moser and Irish journalist Barry Malone. It is one powerful deconstruction of Zionism that I invite you to amplify. Benjamin Moser is excellent, please add him to your list of public intellectuals you follow.

Published by Justina Poskeviciute

Justina is an independent political commentator, writer, and nonprofit professional, with a focus on anticolonial, feminist, antiwar, and climate-justice movements.

Leave a Reply