“Don’t you condemn the violence?”
As the people of Gaza have broken out of their prison, this is the question you might hear thrown at you.
I have some questions about this question:
What is this question? What’s the intention of asking it?
The answer is clear. How people – especially civilians, and even more tragically, children – are being treated by anyone engaged in combat should be something everyone cares about.
Why would you want to wish suffering onto anyone, why would you be OK with that?
And if you don’t, it’s only natural to want to understand how violence operates. What political violence is (a hint that’s too easy: it’s in the name).
What’s the context of what we’re seeing?
What’s the power dynamic here? (Please read that again)
Who’s the occupier, who’s the occupied?
Who’s a nuclear state, who are people without an army?
Which group is colonising the other? Demolishing homes and schools?
Does your analysis only go to the election of Hamas, or can it go at least back to 1948? (It’s not a rhetoric/passive-aggressive question, it’s an actual one.)
And talking about more recent history: who has been kept under a siege – a form of collective punishment, illegal under international law – for 15 years? What has been its effect on the population under it?
This isn’t all one needs to know. There’s no “all” anyways.
But the real question is: in addition to condemning it, do you want to understand where that violence is coming from?
I hope you do 
Justina
Find all my work on Palestine here.
Latest from the Blog
An Interview on Iran and Israel You Have to See
This is an absolute must-watch: Jeremy Scahill, one of the few journalists who interviews and is trusted by various actors, including the Iranian government, talks to Samir Mohyeddin about the U.S.-Iranian negotiations and Israel’s “fragile ceasefires” in Gaza and Lebanon. It’s a conversation good for our brains and conscience.
When Words Become Both The Representation And The Represented
The simplest propaganda technique – blatant lies – might be all that Israel and its supporters have left in their toolbox. Yet words with no meaning is what our leaders, too, have been resorting to for years now, following Israel itself.
Israel: The Only Country Whose Actions Never Represent Itself
If it is not its ministers, navy, police, prison guards, people marching on the streets, nor settlers protected by the army, who, then, actually represents Israel?
The Exploding Head Media 
One thought on ““Don’t You Condemn The Violence?””